Comments on: Wuthering Heights Illuminator post 4 Derrick Truax http://journaling.clsd.net/mr_shank/2009/03/08/wuthering-heights-illuminator-post-4-derrick-truax/ Shanks for Bloggin! Wed, 03 Jun 2009 02:46:57 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.2 hourly 1 By: Megan Douglas http://journaling.clsd.net/mr_shank/2009/03/08/wuthering-heights-illuminator-post-4-derrick-truax/comment-page-1/#comment-546 Megan Douglas Mon, 09 Mar 2009 02:32:15 +0000 http://journaling.clsd.net/mr_shank/?p=595#comment-546 Sorry this is after 8. I checked earlier and didn't see Derrick's post at 5 tonight. Anyway, I am not sure that this quote has anything to do with Catherine's separation from Heathcliff, but rather her own faults. Perhaps the author is trying to say that even though her physical body is gone, she must get rid of the actions she performed while in that body. I agree that this quote is slightly creepy, for this is not a normal action taken by a sane person. It is indeed Heathcliff's fault that he left Catherine and the actions he has taken should be blamed on him not anyone else. I think that he did not marry Catherine because he was scared of Earnshaw. I also think that he had the potential of receiving more money if marrying Isabella. -Megan Douglas Sorry this is after 8. I checked earlier and didn’t see Derrick’s post at 5 tonight. Anyway, I am not sure that this quote has anything to do with Catherine’s separation from Heathcliff, but rather her own faults. Perhaps the author is trying to say that even though her physical body is gone, she must get rid of the actions she performed while in that body.

I agree that this quote is slightly creepy, for this is not a normal action taken by a sane person. It is indeed Heathcliff’s fault that he left Catherine and the actions he has taken should be blamed on him not anyone else. I think that he did not marry Catherine because he was scared of Earnshaw. I also think that he had the potential of receiving more money if marrying Isabella.

-Megan Douglas

]]> By: Brett Pallas http://journaling.clsd.net/mr_shank/2009/03/08/wuthering-heights-illuminator-post-4-derrick-truax/comment-page-1/#comment-542 Brett Pallas Mon, 09 Mar 2009 01:46:58 +0000 http://journaling.clsd.net/mr_shank/?p=595#comment-542 What I made of this was that maybe she does'nt want to be in heaven becuase then she would be seperated from Mr. Heathcliff becuase this whole book was about there love but they didn't want to love each other, but then when they get together Catherine has to go and die. Awesome. Well if you spent a long time trying to get a girl you love deep within your "loins" then I am pretty sure smashing your face into a tree would release some anger and sadness. Is there a point in living if you just lost your true love??forever????? I thought that quote was pretty beast and man-ly What I made of this was that maybe she does’nt want to be in heaven becuase then she would be seperated from Mr. Heathcliff becuase this whole book was about there love but they didn’t want to love each other, but then when they get together Catherine has to go and die. Awesome.

Well if you spent a long time trying to get a girl you love deep within your “loins” then I am pretty sure smashing your face into a tree would release some anger and sadness. Is there a point in living if you just lost your true love??forever????? I thought that quote was pretty beast and man-ly

]]> By: Heather Kinney http://journaling.clsd.net/mr_shank/2009/03/08/wuthering-heights-illuminator-post-4-derrick-truax/comment-page-1/#comment-530 Heather Kinney Mon, 09 Mar 2009 00:03:06 +0000 http://journaling.clsd.net/mr_shank/?p=595#comment-530 Okay, for the first quote, I can agree that Catherine wouldn't want to be stuck forever in heaven with the new personality she developed. The way she was before is obviously who she wants to be, because she likes the life she had with Heathcliff far better than the way she is with Edgar, and we can see that when Heathcliff visits and she gets giddy earlier in the book. The second, one thing I have to say, if you were completely in love with someone, and you find out they died, you might do a little bit more than cry. This isn't a really good connection, but in movies, people die inside when they find out the love of their lives passed away. They cry, yell, seclude themselves from others, even stop eating and sleeping. Okay, for the first quote, I can agree that Catherine wouldn’t want to be stuck forever in heaven with the new personality she developed. The way she was before is obviously who she wants to be, because she likes the life she had with Heathcliff far better than the way she is with Edgar, and we can see that when Heathcliff visits and she gets giddy earlier in the book.

The second, one thing I have to say, if you were completely in love with someone, and you find out they died, you might do a little bit more than cry. This isn’t a really good connection, but in movies, people die inside when they find out the love of their lives passed away. They cry, yell, seclude themselves from others, even stop eating and sleeping.

]]>